Supreme Court Rules States Can Require Sales Tax for Online Purchases

Supreme Court rules that states may require online retailers to collect sales taxes

The 5-4 court opinion finally recognizes the impact of the internet and acknowledges commerce has changed since the court ruled in the 1960s and early 1990s that businesses had to have a physical presence in the state before the state could require them to collect state and local sales taxes.

South Dakota, the subject of Thursday's Supreme Court ruling, passed a law requiring sellers to collect a 4.5 percent sales tax if they had more than $100,000 in annual sales or more than 200 transactions.

"The Internet's prevalence and power have changed the dynamics of the national economy", the court said in its decision in the case, South Dakota v. Wayfair. Large retailers including Apple, Macy's, Target and Walmart, which have brick-and-mortar stores nationwide, already generally collect sales tax from their customers who buy online.

While the ruling opens the door for states to collect taxes from online businesses, there're some significant outstanding questions now that the court has made its decision.

Only five states do not have a state-wide sales tax: Alaska, Delaware, Montana, New Hampshire, and Oregon. But the tax is not applied to third-party sales through the Amazon network.

"You could take it and lower everybody's sales tax rate or everybody's income tax rate, or you could devote it to teacher pay or school construction", said Andy Ellen, president of the North Carolina Retail Merchants Association. He continued to write "the rule produces an incentive to avoid physical presence in multiple states".

The United States Supreme Court just issued a once-in-a-generation ruling for sales tax policy on Thursday.

Verizon, AT&T and Sprint to stop selling location data of customers
In an email to the AP, AT&T spokesman Jim Greer cited similar reasons for cutting off the intermediaries "as soon as practical". The New York Times revealed how a former Mississippi County sheriff used Securus to get location data without a warrant.

Chief Justice John G. Roberts Jr. disagreed in his dissent. Pointing to the company's ads, he wrote: "What Wayfair ignores in its subtle offer to assist in tax evasion is that creating a dream home assumes solvent state and local governments". They often don't have the resources to handle the patchwork of sales taxes across multiple states, according to the retailers, while larger outlets like Amazon don't have that problem.

"Any adjustment to those rules with the potential to disrupt the development of such a critical segment of the economy should be undertaken by Congress", Roberts wrote.

Last November, the federal Government Accountability Office estimated that states could have collected between $8.5 billion and $13.4 billion in sales taxes in 2017 if they had expanded taxing authority.

South Dakota then filed a lawsuit to declare that the new law was valid, a suit that eventually found its way to the Supreme Court.

It's a huge win for vendors with physical storefronts which have long argued that their online counterparts enjoyed an unfair advantage since they didn't have to charge customers local sales tax. The next step will be to see how strictly the courts interpret this ruling, specifically, whether it would allow states to force retailers to also pay excise taxes-also known as OTP taxes-on products.

Chief Justice John Roberts dissented, along with Justices Stephen Breyer, Sonia Sotomayor and Elena Kagan, saying US lawmakers should take up the issue.

Shares of Amazon, Overstock.com, Etsy, Wayfair and other retailers fell after the ruling was announced.

Related:

  • Research 'most compelling evidence ever' of viral trigger for Alzheimer's

    Research 'most compelling evidence ever' of viral trigger for Alzheimer's

    Fargo said the new study "increases the credibility" of previous theories that have linked infectious disease and Alzheimer's. It's nearly certainly the case that these viruses have been in the bodies of the affected people for a long time, said Fargo.
    Lewis Hamilton not concerned by engine upgrade delays

    Lewis Hamilton not concerned by engine upgrade delays

    The Circuit Paul Ricard last hosted a Grand Prix in 1990, when home favourite Alain Prost won for Ferrari . "It is one of the most handsome places in the world".

    Melania Trump's jacket skewered by celebrities from Chelsea Handler to Jim Carrey

    In a dramatic reversal of his previous stance, Mr Trump signed an executive order to keep families together at the border. But President Trump took to Twitter to clarify the harsh message - which he insistedwas aimed at the media.
  • Photo showing Melania Trump in 'don't care' jacket is real

    Photo showing Melania Trump in 'don't care' jacket is real

    A White House official confirmed to NPR that the first lady lobbied her husband to keep undocumented immigrant families together. Melania broke her silence on the detentions which have seen immigrant children separated from their families earlier this week.
    Lakers not inviting LiAngelo Ball to join summer league team

    Lakers not inviting LiAngelo Ball to join summer league team

    They were determined to make this a basketball decision but as one source put it, "obviously there's more to it than basketball". LaVar was asked about his son's next step after not being drafted, and he gave a very non-Ball Family response.
    Melania Trump dons 'I really don't care, do u?' jacket

    Melania Trump dons 'I really don't care, do u?' jacket

    Her spokeswoman Stephanie Grisham said the first lady wasn't sending a message with the jacket . "It's a jacket . First lady Melania Trump boards a plane at Andrews Air Force Base, Md., June 21, 2018 , to travel to Texas .
  • SBA Administrator McMahon's Statement on Association Health Plans

    SBA Administrator McMahon's Statement on Association Health Plans

    The rule grandfathers in previously existing AHPs which are permitted to operate under previous guidance. The final rule comes as a result of an executive order signed by President Donald Trump in October 2017.
    Cavs' Altman says there's a 'good dialogue' with James

    Cavs' Altman says there's a 'good dialogue' with James

    Every day until LeBron James makes his decision, new reports will surface about where the best player in the game will sign. Sexton's arrival completes last summer's Kyrie Irving trade with Boston.
    Last Reservoir of Universe's Missing Ordinary Matter Found

    Last Reservoir of Universe's Missing Ordinary Matter Found

    Next, the researchers pointed the European Space Agency's XMM-Newton satellite in the direction of the elusive baryons. They suspect that it was blown out over billions of years from galaxies and quasars, but how is an open question.
  • Apple App Store Antritrust Case Is Headed to the Supreme Court

    Apple App Store Antritrust Case Is Headed to the Supreme Court

    If the court rules against Apple , it could lead to a huge shift in how the companies behind apps distribute their content. The appeals court "expressly opened the door to duplicative recoveries by different plaintiff groups", Apple argued.
    How to complete Fortnite Week 8 treasure and search seven gnomes

    How to complete Fortnite Week 8 treasure and search seven gnomes

    Second is to get three (3) suppressed weapon eliminations, and last is to eliminate three opponents while in Pleasant Park . Speaking of searching for seven (7) chests, the third challenge is to find seven chests in a single match.
    Recently discovered ancient sea creature named after Obama

    Recently discovered ancient sea creature named after Obama

    The work was performed in collaboration with James Gehling of the South Australian Museum in Adelaide, a co-author on the papers. It was a long time coming, but Obamus coronatus finally got discovered and received a name - and a presidential one at that.

Comments

Latest news

Nigeria players bag $345000 bonus after Iceland win
Iceland had a chance to get one back but Gylfi Sigurdsson sent a penalty kick way over the Nigeria bar in the 83rd minute. Should Nigeria pull off an upset, Argentina will need to beat Nigeria and hope Iceland are beaten or draw with Croatia .

Melania Trump wears 'I really don't care' jacket before visiting migrant kids
Hours later, President Trump offered another view on Twitter , saying that it was directed at the "fake news media ". Critics assumed that she was making a statement about the immigrant children who were separated from their families.

Trump’s migrant policy: First blowback, then about-face
Essentially, this means that after the 20-day mark, children may still be separated from their parents. Trump admitted himself that the "sight" of the children being caged was a big reason for his decision.

Joe Jackson Hospitalized With Terminal Cancer, Being Kept Away From Family
The Jacksons are now in dialogue with the people looking after Joe, and they are being kept informed". Michael Jackson's talent manager dad Joe guided his children to showbiz success as The Jackson 5 .

Italy to seize NGO rescue ships as migrant row deepens
National border controls would undermine the EU's system of free travel and could cause a German government crisis. Some 640,000 migrants have landed in Italy since 2014.

Trump Reportedly Threw Starburst At Angela Merkel During G7 Summit
In the end he agreed and said, okay, I'll sign it. "Here, Angela, don't say I never give you anything", he said. After the G7 summit, Trump attacked Trudeau again and withdrew his support for the communiqué.

Dimitrov wins tough opener at Queen's
There was less humour in third seed Kevin Anderson's day, however, as he was beaten 7-6 (7-4) 4-6 7-6 (7-3) by Leonardo Mayer. Murray has won Queen's a record five times and has never lost to Kyrgios in his five meetings with the volatile Australian.

Kate Spade New York Donates $1 Million To Mental Health Organizations
She founded the company with her husband Andy Spade in 1993 and opened the company's first retail store in NY three years later. According to the National Institute of Mental Health , 18% of American adults suffer from a form of mental illness.

NBC decides it's time to cancel 'Timeless'
The network and studio Sony Pictures Television had been in talks for weeks, leaving the show in limbo. Everything from '60s glam to Civil War uniforms and colonial MA garb.

Serbia vs Switzerland: Battling Swiss unchanged for Serbia showdown
Switzerland is ranked 6th while Serbia ranks 34th in the World Rankings. Tensions have been building in Serbia ahead of the Switzerland match.

Brexit: Theresa May Avoids Defeat Over "Meaningful Vote"
But it was dismissed as a fudge by Scottish National Party leader Nicola Sturgeon and described as meaningless by Labour whips. Shadow Brexit secretary Sir Keir Starmer accused Mr Davis of trying to "sideline Parliament when its voice is most needed".

Rex couldn't stick out its tongue, study finds
The hyoid bones of extinct species of the past were compared to the hyoid bones of present-day avian species and alligators. Judging from the findings, researchers assumed tongues became more flexible as the creatures developed the ability to fly.

New sales tax ruling to spike retail prices online
The Supreme Court has ruled 5-4 (pdf) to greenlight state sales tax for online purchases, reversing a decade-old precedent. The department will be analyzing the court's decision but was "pleased" with the ruling, according to a statement.

NBA Draft 2018: Lakers and Sixers reportedly trade second-round picks
In his senior season at college, Svi really took a big step forward for Kansas, as he averaged 14.6 points per game. The 6-foot-11 Wagner entered the draft after leading the Wolverines to the NCAA Tournament championship game.

SpaceX lands Air Force Falcon Heavy launch contract
Specifically, the Falcon Heavy rocket will be launching the Evolved Expendable Launch Vehicle into its intended orbit. The test program is supposed to be an experimental launch where the Falcon Heavy will carry as many as 25 satellites.

Other news